This baseball off-season has certainly had its share of winners and losers. From the Santana sweepstakes to the Mitchell Report, this off-season has stirred up more controversy and created more headlines than any other professional sport. Here is a quick run down of the who sh-t the bed and who f-cked the prom queen:
Winners:
1) Detroit Tigers--Big trade for the wildcats! They picked up future Hall of Famer Miguel Cabrera and pitcher Dontrelle Willis in exchange for 5 minor leaguers. Cabrera is under contract for the next two seasons and makes the Tigers lineup downright scary. Willis has gotten progrssively worse since his 22 win campaign in 2005. The potential is still there, but the Marlins' firesale tendencies appear to have taken their toll. Look for the D-Train to rebound as a 3rd starter for Detroit with plenty of run support. Although the Tigers traded top prospects Andrew Miller and Cameron Maybin, there is no guarantee with those players. The Tigers have put themselves in contention with the Yankees and Red Sox for the AL pennant.
2) Washington Nationals-- Credit Jim Bowden, GM for the Nationals, who practically stole Lastings Milledge from the Mets and left nothing but a 'late pass' behind. Milledge is a 5 tool outfielder who is only 22 years old. He has potential all-star written all over him. Meanwhile, in return, the Mets received Brian Schneider, a 32 year old defensive catcher whose skills are declined and is owed about $10 million for the next two seasons. Although Schneider's defense is an upgrade over LoDuca, the jump is not worth the organization's best prospect. Last off-season, Minaya could have traded Milledge for A's pitcher Joe Blanton. Instead, Minaya ended up with a 32 year old catcher whose best seasons are behind him. In addition, Bowden also picked up low risk-high reward Devil Rays outfielder Elijah Dukes, a problem child with potential. An outfield of Kearns, Milledge, Willy Mo Pena and Dukes could be a factor for the Nats for years to come.
3) Los Angeles Dodgers-- The boys in blue jumped on Manager Joe Torre the second he was was insulted with a one year deal by the Yankees. Although Torre may not have the same caliber of player he had in New York, he is a good fit for a big market club who will take off all the media pressure and teach the players how to win together. In addition, the Dodgers stole Andruw Jones for a two year $38 million deal. Jones is only 31 and will play a quality centerfield as he seeks to re-establish his ability and get a new contract.
4) Minnesota Twins--The Twinkies have yet to trade Santana, but they have still had a great off-season simply with their trade for Delmon Young. A former #1 pick, Young had over 90 RBI's as a rookie and has the potential for multiple all-star apperances down the road. Although the Twins gave up Garza and Bartlett, those players lack the potential impact of Young. I hear whispers of Frank Robinson for Milt Pappas. The trade of Bartlett was easily replaced with the signing of defensive whiz Adam Everett from Houston.
Losers:
1) San Francisco Giants: Although they did the right thing in letting Barry Bonds walk and saving themselves his $20 million salary, the Giants have done very little this offseason to get better. The team has pitching potential in Matt Cain and Tim Lincecum, but lacks a proven run producer. To solve this dilemma, the team decided to throw $60 million at free agent Aaron Rowand. Rowand is a solid player and "good clubhouse guy," but is unlikely to hit more than 25 home runs next season. Moreover, the five year commitment is a big long for a guy whose first healthy season was last year. The Giants would have been better off signing Andruw Jones instead.
2) Seattle Mariners: In a bare market for free agents, the Mariners rewarded starting pitcher Carlos Silva to a 4-year $48 million contract. This pitcher has had a losing record the last two season and an average ERA of about 5!! Clearly, the Seattle brass appreciated Silva's ability as a innings-soaker. The guy can give you 200 innings. Whether those innings are quality is anyone's guess. Seattle might as well have retained Horacio Ramirez to soak up the innings, and spent their money on some offense. In addition, the M's declined Jose Guillen's option of $9 million so he could sign with the Royals for $36 million. The M's should have picked up the option and then traded Guillen to a team like the Royals to net some prospects, like the Yankees did with Sheffield a year ago. Instead, Guillen gets $36 million and the M's got zip.
3) New York Mets--The off-season is almost over and the Mets have done nothing to make themselves a better team that was one win away from the post-season last year. They traded away Milledge and signed 2B Luis Castillo to a 4-year contract. Neither of those moves are likely to make an impact and instead make the Mets older and more obligated to declining players. Without the propects to go after Santana or Haren, the Mets are left to lean on an ailing Pedro Martinez as their number one starter.
4) Cincinnati Reds--The Reds have too many outfielders and first basemen with Adam Dunn, Scott Hattenberg, Ken Griffey, Josh Hamilton, Ryan Freel, Jay Bruce, Joey Votto all capable. They seem ripe to a big trade to land a quality player like Cabrera or Santana. Instead, they sit tight and spend $46 million on closer Francisco Cordero. Although he had a great season last year, he is far from dominant and even had only less blown save than incumbent Dave Weathers. What a waste!

